Which Type Of Transmission Is Most Reliable?

The AutoGuide Creators Series tells stories and amplifies creators from the car world, including family life, car buying advice, commuting tips, and car culture.

Transcript:

Which transmissions are safe and which ones should you avoid? That’s what we’re going to find out. Welcome to Car Help Corner, where we help you, the consumer, master the process of car buying and ownership. Buying a new vehicle can seem confusing given how many engine and transmission types exist today. In this video, I’m going to compare the most common transmissions, go through the pros and cons of each, how to maintain them properly, whether they’re reliable, and which ones you may want to avoid to dodge major problems.

CVT Transmission

Let’s begin with one of the most controversial transmission types: the CVT (continuously variable transmission). Instead of gears, a conventional CVT uses a metal belt circulating between a pair of pulleys. The benefits are improved fuel economy and a smooth, seamless feel as you accelerate or decelerate. CVTs have become very common across the industry, especially on smaller vehicles.

There are, however, drawbacks. Early CVTs were often problematic and sometimes failure-prone. Honda, Subaru, Hyundai, Kia, and others had issues when CVTs were first introduced. Thankfully, most have sorted out these problems, and over the past decade CVT reliability has improved significantly to the point where it’s no longer a major concern for those brands.

The major exception is Nissan, which uses CVTs made by Jatco, a supplier infamous for high failure rates. Nissan has used Jatco CVTs for over two decades, and premature failure remains common—even on newer models—showing how fragile these transmissions can be. Failures under 100,000 miles (160,000 km) are not unusual.

CVTs are also difficult to repair or rebuild. The typical fix for a failed unit is full replacement, which can easily cost around $8,000. More frequent fluid changes can help prolong lifespan; I recommend changing CVT fluid every ~30,000 miles (50,000 km) to be safe. Still, Jatco CVTs are inherently weak and fragile by design.

To be safe, only buy a vehicle with a CVT from a brand with proven reliability—Honda, Subaru, and Toyota have used CVTs for over a decade and seem to have figured out how to make them stronger and longer-lasting. Overall, I give conventional CVTs from those brands a B– rating. Nissan CVTs get an F.

DCT Transmission

Next up: the DCT (dual-clutch transmission), a form of automated manual. It’s essentially a proper manual transmission with two computer-controlled clutches that change gears. The goal is efficiency and quick shifts.

Downsides? Many. DCTs can be rough, jerky, and fumble gears—like a brand-new driver learning a stick for the first time. Despite software updates, these issues often persist, and some automakers even claim it’s “normal operation.” These problems can lead to premature failure, which has been common on many vehicles with DCTs from Hyundai, Kia, Volkswagen, Ford, and others.

DCTs are also extremely complicated and difficult to repair. Many transmission shops won’t touch them; a failure often means full replacement, typically $8,000–$10,000. If you own one, change the fluid every 30,000 miles (50,000 km)—usually a simple drain-and-fill like a manual. The safest move, though, is to avoid DCTs in everyday vehicles. They can be great in sports cars where fast shifting is a benefit, but for daily driving, definitely not. Rating: D.

Automatic Transmission

Now for the familiar option: the conventional torque-converter automatic. Vehicles have used these for decades, and in many ways they remain among the best. Older versions had 4- or 5-speeds; newer ones commonly have 6-, 8-, or even 10-speeds.

Compared to a DCT, a torque-converter automatic is much smoother. Gear changes are often seamless, they can be just as fuel-efficient, and reliability/repairability is generally better. Most are fine with a fluid change every 60,000 miles (100,000 km). When issues do arise at higher mileage, parts are more available and shops can often repair or rebuild them.

Reliability varies by brand and model. Some are excellent—like the ZF 8-speed used by many brands and Mazda’s 6-speed. Others have issues—like the Ford/GM 10-speed used on many trucks and SUVs. So regular automatics aren’t a guaranteed win; it depends on the specific vehicle. In general, though, they’re one of the safest choices. Rating: B+.

ECVT Transmission

There is one automatic that’s far superior from a reliability standpoint: the ECVT (electronic continuously variable transmission). You’ll find it in many hybrids from Toyota, Lexus, Ford, and Subaru. (Honda markets its hybrids as having an e-CVT, but their system is functionally different and doesn’t use a conventional transmission.)

The “real” ECVT in those other hybrids uses a planetary gear set—a simple arrangement of metal gears—to manage power from the engine and motors to the wheels. The key takeaway: this is easily the simplest, most robust, most reliable automatic in existence. It’s near failure-proof and typically lasts the life of the vehicle. Transmission failures are practically unheard of.

A simple drain-and-fill every 60,000 miles (100,000 km) is more than enough—and many owners stretch it even longer. People say hybrids add complexity, but in many ways they remove it and improve reliability. The ECVT is the best example. Rating: A.

Manual Transmission

Finally, the manual transmission—rare these days, but still beloved. Shifting gears yourself may seem archaic, but manuals have many benefits and few downsides (unless you consider shifting too much work). Next to the ECVT, the manual is the simplest transmission type. They’re repairable, rebuildable, and with fluid changes every 30,000 miles (50,000 km), they can last the life of the vehicle—assuming you drive and clutch properly.

As a bonus, manuals are a decent anti-theft device—many thieves avoid them. Rating: A.

I hope you found this helpful. If you did, please like and subscribe. If you’d like more videos breaking down different car features and technologies—what’s reliable and what to avoid—let me know in the comments.

If you’re planning to purchase a vehicle in Ontario, remember OMVIC is the vehicle sales regulator responsible for administering and enforcing the rules dealerships must follow. Learn more about your consumer protection rights at omvic.ca. For additional car-buying advice, recommendations, or help negotiating a great deal on your next new car, visit carhelpcanada.com.

Thanks so much for watching, and see you next time.

Become an AutoGuide insider. Get the latest from the automotive world first by subscribing to our newsletter here.