Shoppers Are Forcing Tesla To Make A Tough Choice

For a brand that once commanded more than 80 percent of the EV segment, the contrast is stark. The decline hammers home Tesla’s struggle to maintain momentum with its aging lineup. The Model 3 and Model Y—the backbone of the company's sales success—have only truly seen mid updates from the automaker in recent years.

The Cybertruck, launched in 2023, hasn’t reached the blockbuster success expected of it, and recent updates to the Model Y fell short of expectations. According to Reuters, sales still grew slightly in August, but Tesla’s 3.1 percent increase falls well short of the broader EV market’s 14 percent jump.

Naturally, if you're familiar with statistics, you'll quickly understand that outsized gains are harder to come by the more market share you command. Tesla was always doomed to grow at a slower pace than its rivals with a smaller piece of the pie—but that doesn't mask the rate of decline for the American automaker.

Legacy automakers like Hyundai, Kia, Honda, and Toyota are aggressively cutting prices and rolling out incentives, with some brands boosting sales between 60 and 120 percent. That has made Tesla’s relatively modest discounts less effective.

Meanwhile, total U.S. EV sales surged to over 128,000 in July, driven by buyers rushing to secure a federal $7,500 tax credit before it expires at the end of September.

CEO Elon Musk has shifted much of Tesla’s attention away from new vehicle launches and toward long-term projects like robotaxis and humanoid robots.

Investors are watching closely, especially after the company’s board floated a staggering $1 trillion pay package tied to Musk’s ambitious growth targets. For Tesla, the choice is clear—cut prices and risk margins, or hold the line and watch competitors keep stealing customers.

Of course, there's a third choice as well: launch a new product that excites shoppers in ways the original Model 3 and Model Y launches did.

Become an AutoGuide insider. Get the latest from the automotive world first by subscribing to our newsletter here.