Over 140 Fake Carvana Listings Found On Google Across 39 States

AutoGuide News Staff
by AutoGuide News Staff

Carvana built its business model around skipping traditional brick-and-mortar showrooms in favor of online car buying and home delivery. However, an industry investigation reveals that dozens of local Google Business Profile listings tied to the online retailer have been pointing shoppers to physical addresses where Carvana does not actually operate.


According to an analysis published by Car Dealership Guy (CDG News) in collaboration with automotive search researcher Chris Wood, investigators reviewed 327 Google Business Profiles linked to Carvana. While 106 corresponded to legitimate company infrastructure—such as inspection centers, logistics hubs, vehicle vending machines, and the company's seven franchised Stellantis dealerships—another 143 listings used street addresses belonging to completely unrelated properties across at least 39 states and Washington, D.C.


Of those 143 questionable listings, 77 mapped to civic or government buildings, while 66 pointed to unrelated retail storefronts, private residences, and empty parking lots. By November 12, following public scrutiny, 139 of those 143 panels had disappeared from search results altogether.

Shoppers Sent to Jewelry Stores and Empty Lots

While Carvana operates an e-commerce platform competing with retailers like CarMax and AutoNation, having verified local map pins boosts visibility in regional "used cars near me" search queries. In practice, however, those pins sent real buyers to dead ends:


  • Appleton, Wisconsin: A local listing directed prospective car shoppers to the front door of an independent jewelry store.
  • Santa Fe, New Mexico: A customer who drove to an advertised location found no dealership on-site and reported that Google Maps rejected subsequent user attempts to correct the address.

Policy and Legal Gray Areas

In response to initial findings in October, Carvana stated that its local listings were intended to help regional shoppers discover inventory available for delivery or pickup in their areas, noting that physical lot locations are less central to an e-commerce model.


Whether the listings violated platform rules remains murky. Google’s standard vehicle advertising policies generally require dealers to maintain a physical retail presence in the state where inventory is listed, though Google also operates a newer beta program allowing national online retailers to advertise delivery inventory across broader markets.


Still, automotive legal experts note that registering business profiles at third-party commercial or government addresses risks drawing regulatory scrutiny under Unfair or Deceptive Acts or Practices (UDAP) statutes—while leaving frustrated shoppers out time and fuel after driving to phantom lots.


This article was written using AI and was then edited and optimized by our editorial team.


Become an AutoGuide insider. Get the latest from the automotive world first by subscribing to our newsletterhere.

AutoGuide News Staff
AutoGuide News Staff

More by AutoGuide News Staff

Comments
Join the conversation
Next