Cheap vs Expensive Sports Car Tires: Does Price Really Equal Grip?

Ross Ballot
by Ross Ballot
Image: Firestone

Does the old trope "you get what you pay for" really ring true when it comes to performance-oriented summer tires? Consumer Reports set out to see if there really is a correlation, though the findings aren't as clear-cut as you might expect.

Image: Bridgestone

First, some lingo: Theoretical tire quality is rated on the Uniform Tire Quality Grading (UTQG) scale, though it's not perfectly apples-to-apples across the board since each manufacturer assigns scores to their own tires.


Consumer Reports (CR) put 14 high-performance summer tires through the wringer in a bid to find out if the so-called more premium (i.e., more expensive) tires are in fact better when it comes to reality, and whether the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) traction scale (AA, A, B, C) is true to form.


From the test track, CR found that only the Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 ($149/tire in the tested size) was the sole tire not capable of hitting the AA UTQG score. And yet, it still brought home an A rating overall.

Source: Continental Tires

What's really interesting is that the grading gave 13 tires — roughly 93% for you math aficionados —an AA rating. This includes everything from the budget-minded Sumitomo HTR Z5 ($147/tire) to the most costly tire in the test, the Michelin Pilot Sport 4s ($242/tire).


Here's the catch: As Jalopnik points out, Tire Rack's (perhaps even more thorough) testing reveals slightly different results. Instead of the Michelins being best-in-test, Continental's Extreme Contact Sport 02 gets the nod. Ratings (scaled from 0-10) run from 9.5 on the top end to 8.7 on the low end — still excellent.


Long story short, spending less doesn't necessarily mean a dramatically worse tire; in some cases, it might mean something of an equally effective grip. However, it's important to remember that there's more to tires than just sheer grip (in most instances; we're not talking about you track rats out there). Road noise, longevity, and warranty still matter in the real world, and both Consumer Reports' and Tire Rack's respective testing only handles the initial part of a tire's life.


Your mileage may well literally vary.


Become an AutoGuide insider. Get the latest from the automotive world first by subscribing to our newsletterhere.

Ross Ballot
Ross Ballot

Based in Connecticut, Ross hosts The Hooniverse Podcast. He has been in the off-road world since he was a kid riding in the back of his dad’s YJ Wrangler. He works in marketing by day and in his free time contributes to Hooniverse, AutoGuide, and ATV.com, and in the past has contributed to UTV Driver, ATV Rider, and Everyday Driver. Ross drives a 2018 Lexus GX460 that is an ongoing build project featured on multiple websites and the podcast.

More by Ross Ballot

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 3 comments
  • Barry Barry on Oct 02, 2026

    Looking at tire ratings on Tirerack.com, they don't give just a single rating and which one matters to you. If you live in FL, a tire with poor winter ratings may not matter to you. Here in MN it does. An otherwise mid tier rating with excellent winter ratings would be a better choice for us than a top rated tire with a lesser winter rating. Everything is also a trade off. Are you willing to sacrifice peak performance in favor of some other factor. For example on my Corvette, it's michelins only because they are the only ones to make run flats in Corvette sizes. So I'll stick with them even if another tire out performs them. But the michlens do come in a summer only and all season variants. I'm not going to drive it in the winter but the summer only tires have warning not to drive on them when it's less than 40 degrees F. So if I switch to the all seasons I'll sacrifice peak performance but in return can drive the car later in the fall and earlier In the spring.

  • Hat171921562 Hat171921562 on Oct 09, 2026

    I buy cheap Amazon tires, because I drive 80,000 miles a year for work, and I can't afford to be replacing expensive tires all the time. Yes, I know this article is more specifically about performance tires, rather than "daily driver" type tires, I've found several brands of cheap tires to be very, very good in dry conditions, with minimal traction loss in the rain, and only slightly more traction loss in the snow.


    In my opinion, a good indication of just how overpriced tires have become, is when there's a "buy 4 tires, get $300 off" sale or a "buy 3 get the 4th tire free" type promo going on.

Next